Jump to content


Ivan Hakštok

Member Since 05 Sep 2013
Offline Last Active Today, 09:01 AM

#1425836 DoD Robot Results, Shining Month Next

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 30 June 2020 - 10:04 PM

A folk song won? Holy shit, haven't expected this, huge thanks to everyone who voted! There were some really good songs this month.

 

I know my idea isn't very original since Creid exists and Creid is the pinnacle of VGM arrangements but I've always wanted to do some straight up Celtic stuff in DoD and this was a perfect chance to do so. The lead instruments (violin, accordion, pipes, flutes) were all played live on my MIDI keyboard, and some of these lines took me a ton of tries to record properly, the only thing I haven't managed to play completely live is the intro accordion.

 

The last section with the fadeout might've made the song a bit too long but I wanted to have a straightforward folk dance section instead of all the 5/4 - 6/4 shuffling (there's also a 7/8 and 7/4 in there somewhere).


  • 2


#1425743 DoD Robot Entries and Discussion

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 29 June 2020 - 11:47 AM

Reviews:
 
American McGee Presents: Scrapland - Human
 
Cool intro. These are some great rhythm tones! I love the idea of robot vocals, but they're off-beat at some parts. I know that syncing them up better would've taken a lot more time, so consider that a nitpick. Only thing this song is missing is a kickass guitar solo.
 
Chrono Trigger, Chrono Cross - Johnny Races FATE Down Under
 
Down under, where beer does flow and men chunder? I'm getting some Highway Star vibes from this. In my opinion, you should've beefed up the drums just a bit more. I never thought these two themes could fit together, but the FATE part fit in nicely.
 
Cyborg Hunter - Keycards Everywhere.
 
Great selection of sounds, but there's room for improvement in the mix. Drums are good but they could use more punch. Also, don't be afraid to make that lead guitar more wet.
 
Mega Man 2 - Title & Woodman Themes
 
I like the drum sounds. Idk if the bass is just overpowering the leads, but they could definitely use a little volume boost. I'm assuming this is the soundtrack from the Gameboy MM2? This ending part is really good.
 
Mega Man X - OK, Wanger
 
Drums could use less room, they sound a bit muffled. Bass is kinda boomy (haha get it), could've used a midrange or high end boost. Great choices for synth sounds. The pre-outro part is good.
 
Murder By Numbers - Picross Examination
 
I like your style. This is great. I guess my only nitpick is that the lead could be a bit more expressive.
 
NieR: Automata - Copy of a Copy
 
Ah, some acoustics for a change. This atmosphere is great, as is the playing. The percussion mix is good. Oh fuck, there's choirs too. I really like this one.
 
NieR: Automata - Faltering Prayer
 
Another slow NieR track? Great bass tone. Nice usage of sound effects. Not a fan of the brassy synth. The bass synth is dope though. The song drags on for just a bit too long.
 
Rockman & Forte - That's Cold, Man
 
The drums, man, very nice. I love this groove. Cool j-fusion vibes. I just wish there was a halftime section or some other breakdown, the non-stop beat gets a bit tiring.
 
Rockman & Forte - Uhrenmuseum
 
Nice groove, Not a fan of the bass mix, too boomy and not enough "meat". Drums might be a bit overcompressed. Weird ending.
 
Soul Blazer - Dr. Leo's Basement
 
Dancy beat? Interesting. Can't say I like the arrangement though, everything is just too empty and repetitive.
 
Super Robot Wars: Original Generations - The Sword That Cleaves Evil
 
Oh shit, cool intro, great organ sound. Drums sound thin, the kick especially needs more power. Mix could use some improvement, but I like the arrangement. These vocal shouts are great. Nice outro.
 
Undertale - Rehearsing with Mettaton!!!
 
Damn, I like this style. The mix is ok, but there's noticable compression on the drums when the crash cymbals hit. The breakdown section is a good addition, nice and chill.
 
Xenogears - Baile Dúchais
 
Xenogears in celtic style? How original... just kidding, I'm always up for some celtic music. Cool arrangement, not as good as the one from Creid but still pretty good. I like the extra 5/4 parts. I'd give you bonus points for the fadeout but something about it is a bit off, like it should've started a few bars earlier and/or lasted longer.

  • 3


#1423875 Controversial game opinions zone

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 04 June 2020 - 09:34 PM

Eyes on Me > One Winged Angel.

 

Amen


  • 1


#1423482 DoD Golf Vs Fishing Results, Robot Month Next

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 01 June 2020 - 07:38 AM

Congrats to the top 3!

 

I can't believe I made it to 4th considering I started working on my entry pretty late. I was initially gonna cover a different tune from that Mark Davis game since the soundtrack is pretty decent but I couldn't figure out how to finish the arrangement, so I just recorded a quick acoustic take on a different source.

 

I'll be bringing my A-game for Robot Month though! I already have something pretty cool in mind.


  • 1


#1423444 DoD Golf vs. Fishing Entries and Discussion

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 31 May 2020 - 01:22 PM

Reviews:
 
Bandai Golf: Challenge Pebble Beach - Albatross
 
I like your style. Simple and clean. There are some "hiccups" in lead playing but nothing too big. I wish this was longer.
 
Black Bass: Lure Fishing - Black Bass
 
Live violin? Nice. You could've raised the volume on the piano, it isn't competing for space with the violin. Not much else to add.
 
Fishing Vacation - Vacation Blues
 
Percussion could be more in front. Lead timing is a bit off in some parts. I like the change in the 2nd half. Piano fits really nice, but I'm not a fan of the guitar work.
 
Fuzzy's World of Miniature Space Golf - Now That's What I Call Space Golf!
 
I really like this one. Solid playing and a good arrangement.
 
Hal's Hole in One Golf - Metal Play is My Name
 
Great playing! I love the brass lines. This arrangement is fun as hell.
 
Hole in One Golf - CONGRATULATION
 
Pretty chill. But gets repetitive quickly. I don't know if it's the drum sequencing or the guitars, but something is off about the timing.
 
Kirby's Dream Course - Iceberg Ocean
 
Not a fan of the arrangement, takes too long to get to the interesting stuff. Also, it's pretty repetitive. Just changing up the percussion would've helped a lot. The vocals are a nice touch.
 
Legend of the River King - Kawa no Nushi Tsuri
 
I like the rhythms and the drums. Cool lead duel thingy going on there. Nice and fun arrangement. Lead playing in this last part is great.
 
Mario Golf - Great Moments in Golf Glory - The 1999 Marion Cup Recap (Best Shots Replay)
 
Cool idea. Idk why but I'm getting street fighter vibes. Lead playing is great.
 
Mark Davis' The Fishing Master - Guitar Licks For Fish Sticks
 
Nice vibe, I'd go fishing with this playing in the background. Rhythm lacks some sparkle. Lead playing is a bit off. That ending was a bit sudden and weird.
 
Mark Davis' The Fishing Master - Oh No Bass Pun
 
Nice bass tone and drums. The lead could've used some more gain. I like how the arrangement starts out, but it's pretty much on autopilot.
 
NES Open Tournament Golf - Golfing in Overalls
 
Something is off about the mix. Kick is too buried, and the drums are overall pretty machine-gunny. I like the bass work. Changing things up for the 2nd part is a good idea but the transition was weird. Leads are out of tune near the end, and the very ending is weird.
 
Putt and Putter - Butt and Butter, amirite?
 
Another chill track. It sounds to me like there's parts that are played with a swing and parts are just straight notes, makes it sound kinda off.
 
Shimono Masaki no Fishing to Bassing - FIGHING TO BASHING
 
Nice lead playing. I like the bass tone. This arrangement is fun, the halftime section really helps, otherwise it would've been pretty repetitive.
 
The Blue Marlin - Gnarlin Marlin
 
I like the groove. I wish the bass was a bit more in front in this first part. Not a fan of the transition around a minute in. Lead playing is pretty good, and it gets better as the song goes on, but your vibrato could use some improvement, you can hear it's a bit off on the longer notes.

  • 4


#1422349 Controversial game opinions zone

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 17 May 2020 - 12:48 PM

Vagrant Story is on a lot of lists of best rpgs no one ever played, so has anyone actually played it here?  Good game or no?

 

I liked Vagrant Story a lot. I've beaten it several times, including the new game plus extra stuff. It has a great story and soundtrack, but figuring out the battle system and the weapons crafting system can take a while. And if you don't figure it out, even regular enemies can get really difficult.


  • 1


#1421251 Best Official VGM Arrange Album

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 04 May 2020 - 09:50 PM

I've already seen it mentioned in the thread a few times, but it's worth mentioning again and again: nothing will ever top Xenogears Creid.

 

By the way, the live versions of Creid songs from the Xenogears 20th anniversary concert are also awesome, especially Lahan.


  • 2


#1421026 DoD Free Month Results, Golf vs Fishing Month Next

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 02 May 2020 - 01:07 PM

Here's a vid of me playing the rhythm guitar for my entry:

 


  • 4


#1421004 J-Fusion Thread

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 02 May 2020 - 12:24 AM

All early ISS games have cool j-fusion soundtracks.

 

 


  • 1


#1420877 DoD Free Month Results, Golf vs Fishing Month Next

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 30 April 2020 - 10:48 PM

Congrats to the top 3!

 

4th place is better than I expected after hearing the entries, this was really a crazy month. Also, big thanks to Sixto for helping me out (he did the FF6 leads and the 3:06 guitar solo). This arrangement came to me in a dream after trying to beat the pull-up minigame in the FF7 remake for like an hour and going to sleep immediately afterwards. Woke up in the morning and immediately recorded a rough bassline for the first 2-2.5 minutes, then I did the rest of it over the next two days. I'm not usually the guy to cover themes that have been way overdone such as these FF ones, but I figured this kind of mashup would be pretty fresh.


  • 3


#1420623 DoD Free Month Entries and Discussion

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 28 April 2020 - 01:00 PM

This month is craaaaaaazy.

 

Here are some reviews:

 

Baba Is You - Rocket Is Dust
 
Nice chips. Intro goes on a bit too long. I like the sound, mixing chips and guitars is always a plus. This song is good exectuion-wise, but it's just too repetitive for my taste.
 
Batman [NES] - Punch Punch
 
Nice take on this source. I really like the rhyhtm guitars. My only nitpick with this is that it could've been longer, but since it doesn't stray away from the source too much, keeping it short is also a good idea.
 
Blazing Chrome - Time to Blaze
 
Holy shit, I love the sound of this right from the start. Good rhythm tone, also the drums and synths are 80s to the max. I just wish there was a kickass guitar solo for the outro, but this is still great.
 
Chrono Trigger - The Secret of the Forest
 
Interesting spin on the source. I think the vocals should've dropped in sooner, and I wish there was more going on in the background, maybe some more synth work or more backing vocals. I really like the change 5 minutes in, but again, it probably should've happened sooner in the song. Interesting idea, goes on for a bit too long.
 
Contra 3: The Alien Wars, Contra 4 - Let's attack aBRASSively!
 
Bonus points for the brass. Also, nice bass. The snare sound a bit weird to me, maybe not enough smack or a bit too much room. I really like this arrangement. 
 
Environmental Station Alpha - 6-bit
 
Really good lead tone, and I like the atmosphere you're trying to create. There's something off about the balance, the kick is too much in front compared to the rest of the drums, and the lead guitars are way in the back. The arrangement is 
 
Final Fantasy 5, Final Fantasy 6, Final Fantasy 7 - Let The Decisive Battle On The Big Bridge Begin!
 
Great combination of the themes, I like that this is not just a straightforward medley. The solo at round 3:10 is great. The kick is a bit too much thump and not enough thwack, if you get what I mean. Pretty good arrangement.
 
Fire Emblem: Three Houses - God Shattering Star
 
Oh wow. I did not expect vocals like this. This sounds awesome.
 
Mega Man 6 - templant man
 
Chillax to the max. I wish the intro rhythms kept playing together with the lead guitars. Ohshit, FM breakdown. Great idea. This last part lacks low end, you probably could've layered the FM bass with another synth bass.
 
Mega Man - Elec Man (Cello Version)
 
Nice source tune selection, nice cello playing... but that's everything I can say about this. Not much arranging or production going on.
 
Metal Slug - Starry Cinnamon Skies
 
Funky and lovely. Good arrangement and sound. But you gotta work on those lead chops, your vibrato is a bit lacking.
 
NieR: Automata - Milonga del Carnaval de las Máquinas Tristes (Milonga from the Carnival of the Sad Machines)
 
Accordion is always a big plus for me. Good arrangement, but for my own taste a bit too long considering the limited instrumentation. 
 
Ninja Gaiden, Ninja Gaiden II: The Dark Sword of Chaos, Ninja Gaiden III: The Ancient Ship of Doom - Ninja Gaiden Trilogy
 
Nice drums, but the first part gets repetitive quickly. I really like the synths. Not a fan of the transitions between the sources.
 
Pac-Man 2: The New Adventures - Pac-Man 2: 1 Guitar
 
Cool style, done nicely. Not much else to say. Great clean tone.
 
Pictionary - Pictiognarly: Shred the Wet
 
Great lead tone! I like the combination of synths and guitars. The arrangement feels kinda short, especially since there's lots of cool stuff going on in the song.
 
Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire - My Body Is Regi
 
It's like this song can't decide whether to go full techno or full metal so it just gets stuck in limbo. Instrument balance is all over the place, and I'm not feeling the transitions between each section. Your rhythm tone is great though.
 
Punch-Out!! - Finished with Mike Tyson
 
I can notice some good ideas in the arrangement, but the execution isn't there. Drum mix is kinda weak. Whoa, did you get a bit... paranoid there?
 
Resident Evil 4 - SAVE LEON K
 
Is this the first ever RE4 mix on DoD? I like this groove. Gets a bit repetitive but I guess that's due to the source material and the style.
 
Terranigma - Sleepy Seaport
 
Rhythms might be a bit too loud here. The arrangement is okay but I wish it got more powerful as the song went on.
 
Undertale, Touhou 4: Lotus Land Story - That's Bullet Hell You're Walking Into
 
Damn, I was gonna say the intro sounds a bit weak but then it went all crazy and I love it! The synths and the beat are awesome. Guitars are a bit lacking in expression compared to what I'm used to hearing in this style but they don't detract from the rest of the song.
 
Ys 6: The Ark of Napishtim - Ocean SpraYs
 
Great rhythm tone. The kick sounds a bit clicky for my taste. Lead playing is also great and clean. I hoped it would end on a crazy guitar solo, but this is fine too.

  • 3


#1418539 PUNCHFEST 24! - Last one before world ends?

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 06 April 2020 - 01:22 PM

So cool!! 

 

What's your audio routing setup for streaming?  OBS?  Does OBS recognize your mic and Reaper audio, or did you have to do something extra to set it up?

 

I put the Reastream plugin on the master channel in Reaper and set it to send the signal, then I put the same plugin on an audio channel in OBS and set it to receive the signal (OBS can load VST plugins). Microphone also went through Reaper, I turned on the monitoring on the mic track and disabled the input recording.


  • 1


#1418533 PUNCHFEST 24! - Last one before world ends?

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 06 April 2020 - 12:39 PM

Here's the video from my stream, complete with timestamps in the description:

 


  • 1


#1418099 DoD Recover Results, Free Month Next

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 31 March 2020 - 10:11 PM

Congrats PuD/Tiberian Sons! Like I said in the reviews, Full Mast is one of the best DoD songs ever, and your cover is on the same level! Great stuff!

 

 

Now, about my entry: for years I've wanted to cover Inhabitants of the Dwelling, because it's one of the most creative songs in DoD history and because norg is a cool dude whose songs were among the first DoD songs I've ever listened to.

 

So, with my entry I wanted to do a couple of things:

- Cover norg

- Pay tribute to DoD

- Do stuff I've never tried before, in this case making a 20+ minute song

 

I decided to go with relatively new DoD inhabitants for each robot master. I couldn't hide my terrible accent so I pronounced my name wrong intentionally to maybe throw people off. I'm glad people liked it enough to vote it 2nd! Thanks everyone!


  • 4


#1417941 DoD Recover Entries and Discussion

Posted by Ivan Hakštok on 30 March 2020 - 09:28 AM

Chrono Trigger - Time - Lavos - Chance
I love this right from the start. Great sounds, including the vocals. 
 
Ghosts 'n Goblins, Mega Man 7, Castlevania 2: Simon's Quest - Nobody:  Me: Treat Suite, but now it's under 20 minutes
19 minutes? Well, the title didn't lie. Nice vocals. I actually think the drums fit better like this than if they were mixed more in front. The synth lead seems a bit loud, and not expressive enough. Vocal harmonies 8 minutes in are pretty nice. I really appreciate the effort put into this, but some of the parts do get repetitive.
 
Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker, The Legend of Zelda - Full Mast
Incredible. I know it might be blasphemous to say this but this is on the same level as the original, and the original is one of the greatest songs in DoD history!
 
Mass Effect 3 - Leaving Earth
Nice intro. Baaaaaaaaam! Excellent intro, actually. Snare might be too compressed, it doesn't sit that well in the mix. I wish the bass had a little more grit to it, because it sounded really good in those few parts where it was audible.
 
Mega Man 2 - New Inhabitants of the Dwelling: The Return of the Secret of the Electric Boogalooze (Part 1)
Haha, "I understood that reference", the song. Artist impressions sound ok to me buuut you pronounced my name wrong. I really need to teach you guys how to properly pronounce it. Kept me interested for the whole 20 minutes, so I guess the song's ok.
 
Mega Man X - Six-Stringed Sniper
Everything seems in background compared to the bass, you gotta bring those drums and guitars more in front! The guitar playing is pretty good though. Lots of boomines in some parts, make sure you high-pass everything that doesn't need that low end!
 
Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon - Back at the Finja Shack
Damn, another one where I love the original, and you've pretty much nailed it. Great lead guitar at around 3 minutes. The mix sounds a bit muddy in parts.
 
Ninja Gaiden - The Masked Devil
I like your drum sound. Great lead playing. Great song overall.
 
Silent Hill - Out for a Stroll
Don't be afraid to bring that kick drum more in front. The constant velocity on the snare in the main beat is pretty noticeable. Nice tremolo picking clean.
 
Tales of Phantasia - The Feels 2 - The Return of the Sequel's Revenge Part 2 Turbo (Electric Boogaloo)
Nice intro, I dig the acoustic. The kick, the bass and the rhythm guitars are all competing for the same low end space, gotta carve things up with eq there. Sudden ending, ok I guess.
 

  • 2