146 replies to this topic

[MikeyWretch]

Well smashing R2 wouldnt get Kirk any coochie so um this fight would never happen.

[nastyd]

kirk and r2 would make good co-host on a millionaire-type game show.

[chadk]

definitely luke but it's a little unfair

well kirk has years of experience actually finished his star fleet training (i think) and is a master at intergalatic warfare

luke has a small grasp of the force and can fly space ships really well for no real training

[japmonchris]

I I couldnt buy that Hayden dude as Anakin, he was just a whiny bitch.

So was Luke!

"But I was going to the Toshi Station to pick up some power converters!" BOOHOO!

Like father like son i guess, but i think difference was we knew Luke at the beginning of his journey. He started out a whiny bitch, then became a calm, collected, jedi. We knew Anakin as the dude that became Darth Vader, the ultimate bad ass of the galaxy, next to boba fett, of course. Be he started out as a little kid to a little bitch to still a little bitch, just an angrier little bitch. To bad were not practicing tonight, otherwise could continue this in person! HA!

[nastyd]

To bad were not practicing tonight, otherwise could continue this in person! HA!

i canceled practice because of this thread actually. i don't need any more bloody noses at the brothel.

[raubhimself]

definitely luke but it's a little unfair

well kirk has years of experience actually finished his star fleet training (i think) and is a master at intergalatic warfare

luke has a small grasp of the force and can fly space ships really well for no real training

which luke are we talking about here? if we're going by ep. 1 luke, then yeah, kirk wins. but by rotj luke was a jedi knight, and later became jedi master. there's no way kirk could fight a jedi kight, let alone a jedi master.

[donald]

I can't believe Quezo hasn't jumped in on this thread.

[differently biotic]

kirk vs. luke... no weapons? Kirk

now data vs. cp30 or r2 or those lame o robot thingys... data!

[MikeyWretch]

Are we really talking about Kirk being able to fight?

Have any of you seen him fight? Its slower than Cane on kung fu!

[differently biotic]

Are we really talking about Kirk being able to fight?

Have any of you seen him fight? Its slower than Cane on kung fu!

I just see Kirk being more of a hand to hand brut than Luke. young Kirk, not old big belly kirk.

[chadk]

which luke are we talking about here? if we're going by ep. 1 luke, then yeah, kirk wins. but by rotj luke was a jedi knight, and later became jedi master. there's no way kirk could fight a jedi kight, let alone a jedi master.

true, ture. luke when he's in the dagobah system training with yoda and he bails on finishing training

[JRC]

I vote Kirk in the fight.
He's managed to take down every other kind of alien in the galaxy, I don't think a guy who can toss junk at him is gunna be able to bring 'im down.
Mind control? Please that only works on simpletons--maybe Checkov, not The Kirk.

Actually . . . if you think about it, Luke's "story arch" is sort of like starting out as Kirk (hot headed) and evolving into Spock (cold & dispassionate)?


JRC

[JRC]

Boba Fet vs. Spock?

that would be freakin' epic.

JRC

[MikeyWretch]

Are we really talking about Kirk being able to fight?

Have any of you seen him fight? Its slower than Cane on kung fu!

I just see Kirk being more of a hand to hand brut than Luke. young Kirk, not old big belly kirk.

still

[chadk]

can spock fly, how close does he have to get to do the vulcan mind thing?